If you've been doing civil work for a while, you've seen both types: the 200-line-item DOT bid where every CY and LF has its own price, and the private development bid where the owner just wants one number.
Unit price and lump sum bids look different on the page, and they carry different risk. Pricing them the same way is a mistake.
Unit price bidding: how it works
In a unit price bid, you price each line item separately. The owner provides quantities. You provide a price per unit. The contract value is your unit prices × actual quantities.
If the actual quantity is higher or lower than estimated when the job is done, you get paid for the actual installed quantity at your bid unit price.
Unit price is the standard on public civil work: DOT projects, municipal bids, utility programs. The owner's engineer estimates the quantities; you price the units. This protects both parties from quantity uncertainty.
The risk in unit price bids
Your unit price has to work regardless of final quantity. If you price at $11.50/CY assuming 200 CY/hr production and the soil is hard clay at 90 CY/hr, your unit price is underwater on every CY you dig.
Price each item to stand on its own at that unit price. Don't assume quantity growth will bail you out on low-margin items.
Lump sum bidding: how it works
In a lump sum bid, you give the owner one total price for a defined scope of work. The contract value is fixed — if it costs you more, that's your problem. If you finish under budget, that's your profit.
Lump sum is common on private development work: commercial site prep, residential subdivision grading, private utility projects. The owner wants a fixed price. The quantity risk is yours.
The risk in lump sum bids
The entire quantity risk sits with you. What goes wrong:
- Incomplete plans — scope is vague, quantities change
- Site conditions not matching the geotech report
- Scope creep ("while you're here, can you also...")
- Missing items in your takeoff
Side-by-side comparison
| Unit Price | Lump Sum | |
|---|---|---|
| Who provides quantities | Owner's engineer | You |
| Quantity risk | Owner | Contractor |
| Common on | Public (DOT, municipal) | Private development |
| Payment basis | Actual installed quantities | Contract price |
| Adjusts if scope changes | Yes (quantity adjustment) | Requires change order |
The unbalanced bid: don't do it
On unit price bids, some contractors front-load: put high unit prices on early-installed items, low unit prices on later items. The idea is to get more cash in early.
Why this is a problem: owners and engineers look for unbalanced bids and can reject them. If early items come in over estimated quantities, you win — but if later items run over at your below-cost unit prices, you lose money on each one.
Price each item to cover its actual cost at the bid quantity. Period.
How to price unit price items
For each line item, your unit price needs to cover direct cost, overhead allocation, and profit margin.
Formula: Unit price = (Direct cost per unit) × (1 + overhead %) × (1 + margin %)
If your direct cost for 18" RCP installation is $28/LF, at 12% overhead + 10% margin: $28 × 1.12 × 1.10 = $34.50/LF
How to price lump sum bids
- Do your own takeoff. Measure every item from the plans. Don't use the owner's quantities as your starting point.
- Build contingency into uncertain items. Not markup — actual quantity buffer for items with real uncertainty.
- Define your exclusions in writing. Put them in your proposal. Scope creep requires a change order.
Your catalog works for both types
Whether you're doing unit price or lump sum work, the underlying cost data is the same: what does it cost you per CY of excavation, per LF of 8" waterline, per SY of aggregate base?
The difference is how you apply it:
- Unit price: each item price = catalog rate + overhead + margin
- Lump sum: catalog rates × your takeoff quantities = total cost, then add overhead + margin
CivBid builds your catalog automatically as you price bids. Both bid types pull from the same pricing history. Try it with your next ITB at civ.bid/try. No signup required.
Ready to try it?
Upload an ITB PDF and see CivBid extract your line items automatically. No signup required.
Upload an ITB PDF — Try Free